There’s been much discussion over Harris’ heritage since she announced her candidacy. During a visit to The Breakfast Club, Harris attempted to dismiss reports that she is not African-American, saying it’s the same rhetoric that was once used against Barack Obama to divide the country. Harris’ mother is an immigrant from India and her father immigrated from Jamaica. The senator was born in Oakland, California.
After viewing a clip from the interview, Ryan questioned why the “blackness” of mixed-race candidates is always in question. Lemon then cuts her off, believing she missed the point.
“No, no, no, no, no, I think you’re not hearing what people are saying. The people that are saying, ‘is she B
Ryan responds by reiterating that Harris is a “Black woman,” for sure, which Lemon doesn’t dispute.
“I agree with that, but is she African-American? There is a difference, and there’s nothing wrong with that. No one’s trying to take anything away from her. I think you’re falling into the trap of that.”
He went on, “All she had to do was say, ‘I am Black, but I’m not African-American.’”
Ryan then pointed out that slaves from Africa were taken to the Caribbean, as well as the states, to which Lemon responds, “Jamaica’s not America. Jamaica did not come out of Jim Crow.”
As the conversation continues, Lemon suggests that Harris is not an American descendant of slavery, and that Ryan’s argument misses the overall point of those questioning Harris’ cultural identity. See the discussion below.