Connect with us

Black Listed

Ferguson Man Beaten by Cops Wins Appeal

Henry Davis Ferguson Missouri
<p> USA Today</p>

The Ferguson cops charged Henry Davis with destruction of property because he bled on their uniforms when they beat him. Then, as if fearing it might be outdone in ridiculousness, a federal district court ruled that Davis could not sue the cops for violating his Fourth Amendment rights because they had not injured him badly enough as he lay handcuffed on the jailhouse floor, a working man arrested on a traffic warrant in a case of mistaken identity.

“As unreasonable as it may sound, a reasonable officer could have believed that beating a subdued and compliant Mr. Davis while causing only a concussion, scalp lacerations and bruising with almost no permanent damage did not violate the Constitution,” the district court ruled in tossing out the case.

Davis appealed and his attorney James Schottel responded to absurdity with legal reasoning. He argued that the decisive factor was not the seriousness of Davis’s injuries but the nature of the officers’ actions. The district court had ruled that the officers enjoyed “official immunity” because they “acted within their discretion and caused only de minimis [slight] injuries.” Schottel contended that official immunity “does not apply to discretionary acts done in bad faith or with malice.”

The appeals court could not have been clearer in its response on Tuesday. “We agree.”

Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Trending

NYPD Officer Accused of Fatally Choking Eric Garner Fired Five Years After Incident

News

Mike Brown, Michael Brown Mike Brown, Michael Brown

A Look Back on the Death of Mike Brown in Ferguson

EBONY Exclusive

Staten Island Dad dies choke hold Eric Garner, 43,, Eric Garner, DOJ, NYPD Staten Island Dad dies choke hold Eric Garner, 43,, Eric Garner, DOJ, NYPD

Eric Garner: Tall, Dark and Threatening

News

Geneva Reed-Veal Geneva Reed-Veal

EBONY Exclusive: EBONY Talks With Geneva Reed-Veal, Mother of Sandra Bland

EBONY Exclusive

Advertisement
Connect
Join EBONY.com